A fixed-rate annuity (MYGA) and a CD both pay a set rate for a term, but they differ in three ways. A CD is FDIC insured, while a MYGA is backed by the issuing insurer's claims-paying ability. CD interest is taxed every year, while MYGA interest grows tax-deferred. And early withdrawal forfeits interest on a CD, versus surrender charges and a possible 10% IRS penalty on a MYGA before age 59 and a half.
Is this a fit for you?
Who This Is For
- You want tax-deferred growth rather than being taxed on interest each year
- You have a multi-year horizon and will not need the money soon
- You are in a higher tax bracket where deferral helps
- You want a rate that is often higher than comparable CDs
- You are past age 59 and a half or will not touch the gains before then
Who This Is Not For
- You may need the money within a year or two
- You want FDIC backing rather than carrier backing
- You are in a low tax bracket where deferral adds little
- You are under age 59 and a half and might need the gains
- You value simplicity and full liquidity over a higher rate
How do the options compare?
| Feature | Fixed Annuity (MYGA) | Bank CD |
|---|---|---|
| Who backs it | Issuing insurer's claims-paying ability | FDIC insured, up to limits |
| Tax on interest | Tax-deferred until withdrawn | Taxed each year |
| Typical rate | Often higher than a comparable CD | Often lower than a comparable MYGA |
| Early-withdrawal cost | Surrender charges, plus a possible 10% IRS penalty on gains before age 59 and a half | Forfeiture of interest |
| Typical term | 3 to 10 years | 3 months to 5 years |
What are the risks, costs, and alternatives?
A MYGA is not FDIC insured
A MYGA is not FDIC insured and depends on the carrier's claims-paying ability. Its guarantee is only as strong as the issuing insurance company, so the carrier's financial strength rating matters. State guaranty associations provide limited backstops that vary by state. That coverage is not a government guarantee and should not be relied upon in deciding whether to buy or which insurer to choose.
Early withdrawal can cost more on a MYGA
MYGA surrender charges apply above the free-withdrawal amount, and a 10% IRS penalty can apply to gains before age 59 and a half. Match the term to money you are confident you can leave untouched, and know the free-withdrawal limit before you sign.
A CD is taxed annually and often pays less
A CD's interest is taxed annually and its rate is often lower than a comparable MYGA. In a higher tax bracket, paying tax on interest each year reduces what compounds, which is part of why a MYGA can appeal to some savers.
A fixed rate carries inflation risk
A fixed rate on either a MYGA or a CD carries inflation risk over a long term. Locking a rate for several years gives certainty but no inflation adjustment, so the real value of a fixed payout can erode if prices rise.
What does this look like in practice?
Same Safe Money, Different Choices
Illustrative example: not an actual client.
Saver A: deferral and rate. With money they want kept safe for five years, Saver A is in a high tax bracket and has no near-term need for the funds. They dislike paying tax on interest every year. They choose a MYGA for the tax deferral and the often-higher rate, accepting that the guarantee rests on the insurer's claims-paying ability and that early access could trigger surrender charges.
Saver B: backing and access. With the same five-year window, Saver B thinks they may need the funds sooner and wants FDIC backing rather than carrier backing. They choose a CD, accepting annual taxation and a possibly lower rate in exchange for federal deposit insurance and simpler access.
Neither choice is universally better. The decision turned on bracket, horizon, and liquidity, not on one product being right for everyone.
Illustrative scenario for educational purposes. Rates, terms, tax outcomes, and surrender schedules vary by carrier, bank, product, and individual situation. A MYGA is subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurer.
Common Questions
Is an annuity better than a CD?
Neither is universally better. A fixed-rate annuity (MYGA) grows tax-deferred and often pays a higher rate, but it is backed by the issuing insurer's claims-paying ability and can carry surrender charges and a possible 10% IRS penalty on gains before age 59 and a half. A CD is FDIC insured up to limits and simpler, but its interest is taxed every year and its rate is often lower. Which fits depends on your tax bracket, time horizon, and need for liquidity.
Are annuities FDIC insured?
No. Annuities are not FDIC insured. They are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company, not the FDIC or any government agency. A bank CD, by contrast, is FDIC insured up to applicable limits. Carrier financial strength ratings matter most when evaluating an annuity. State guaranty association coverage is limited, varies by state, is not a government guarantee, and should not be relied upon in deciding whether to buy or which insurer to choose.
Do you pay taxes on annuity interest every year?
No. Interest in a MYGA grows tax-deferred, so you are not taxed on it each year while it stays in the contract. You are taxed when you withdraw the gains. CD interest, by contrast, is generally taxed every year even if you leave it in the account. Withdrawing MYGA gains before age 59 and a half can also trigger a 10% IRS penalty.
Related Questions
Choosing Where to Keep Your Safe Money?
We compare MYGA rates against CDs for your tax bracket, time horizon, and liquidity needs, then show you what each option looks like for your situation so you can decide with the full picture in front of you.
Last updated · How we review our content
Living Prepared, LLC is an affiliate of Whitwell & Co., LLC, an SEC-registered investment advisory firm. Insurance and annuity products are offered through licensed insurance professionals. See our Disclosures.